← Back to Learn Investing

What Tesla Is Actually Worth, and Why Investors Disagree So Violently

Companies and Brands You Know • Beginner Investing • 7 min

What this lesson is about

Two informed investors can look at the exact same company and reach completely opposite conclusions. Tesla is one of the clearest real-world examples of exactly why that happens.

2 parts · a quick check after each · then the quiz

Part 1 of 2

Tesla, is, a, prime, example, of, how, two, informed, investors, can, see, the, same, company, and, come, to, totally, different, conclusions, about, its, value., The, bull, case, argues, that, Tesla, is, more, than, just, a, car, company., It, has, potential, in, autonomous, driving,, energy, storage,, solar,, robotics,, and, other, emerging, sectors,, in, addition, to, its, car, manufacturing., Supporters, believe, Tesla's, high, valuation, reflects, the, market's, expectations, for, a, range, of, future, opportunities, that, go, well, beyond, current, car, sales.

The, bear, case, disagrees., At, its, core,, Tesla, is, still, mostly, a, car, manufacturer., It, faces, the, same, economic, challenges, as, traditional, carmakers,, along, with, rising, competition, from, established, brands, and, new, EV, companies., Plus,, it, deals, with, margin, pressures, typical, in, the, auto, industry., Tesla, trades, at, multiples, much, higher, than, traditional, automakers, like, Ford, and, General, Motors., Bears, argue, that, these, high, valuations, assume, a, level, of, future, success, across, various, business, lines, that, might, never, happen.

Quick check

What is a core part of the bull (optimistic) case some investors make for Tesla's valuation?

Part 2 of 2

Insider, Angle:, Neither, side, can, claim, to, be, definitively, right, or, wrong., This, debate, is, ongoing, among, reasonable,, informed, investors., It, hinges, on, different, beliefs, about, which, parts, of, Tesla’s, broader, ambitions, will, succeed,, how, large, they, could, become,, and, how, much, of, that, potential, should, affect, today's, price., Understanding, both, sides, and, their, assumptions, is, more, valuable, than, just, picking, a, conclusion, without, examining, the, reasoning, behind, it.
Try, This:, Find, one, recent,, credible, bull, argument, and, one, recent,, credible, bear, argument, about, Tesla's, valuation., For, each, argument,, identify, the, SPECIFIC, assumption, that, its, conclusion, relies, on, the, most., Think, about, what, needs, to, be, true,, or, not, true,, for, that, assumption, to, hold, up.

Quick check

What is a core part of the bear (skeptical) case some investors make about Tesla's valuation?

Quiz

Master this lesson

Test what you just learned. Correct moves you up, wrong moves you down - reach 100 to master this lesson.

0
/ 100
Log in to save your progress and earn XP.

Related lessons

Swipe for more